Comparative Study of Time Domain, Harmonic Balance and Volterra Series Methods for Nonlinear Circuit Simulation

EL-Sayed, Tamer S.; EL-Rabaie, S.

doi:10.21608/mjeer.2011.66820

Comparative Study of Time Domain, Harmonic Balance and Volterra Series Methods for Nonlinear Circuit Simulation

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

Tamer S. EL-Sayed ¹
S. EL-Rabaie ²

¹ Dept. of Communication and Electronic Engineering Egyptian Russian University

² Dept. of Communication and Electronic Engineering, Minufiya University

10.21608/mjeer.2011.66820

Abstract

onlinear circuit analysis differs from linear circuit analysis in that the transfer characteristic between the input and the output is a function of signal level and the operating point. Different methods were established to manipulate these circuits for different frequency ranges with different excitations. These methods were classified into Time-domain and Frequency domain methods. A brief discussion of each method was mentioned. A simple circuit with a diode which is a nonlinear device was studied for Volterra series and Harmonic Balance methods. Second and third harmonic distortions were calculated for this circuit. Results from Spice and harmonic Balance were arranged for different harmonic amplitudes. The obtained results were compared with the results from SPICE software (Time-domain simulator). A comparative study for the results confirm that for mildly nonlinear circuit the Volterra series is the optimum one, for strong nonlinear circuit a compromise between the accuracy and CPU considerations is the critical parameter for choosing such Harmonic Balance or the SPICE.

References

[1] Rowan J. Gilmore, and Michael B. Steer, "Nonlinear Circuit Analysis Using the Method of Harmonic Balance-A Review of the Art-Part I-Introductory Concepts," International Journal of Microwave and Millimeter-Wave Computer-Aided Engineering, Vol. 1, pp. 22-37, 1991.

[2] Takaaki Kinouchi, Yoshihiro Yamagami, Yoshifumi Nishio, Akio Ushida, "Spice-Oriented Harmonic Balance and Volterra Series Methods," International Symposium on Nonlinear Theory and its Applications NOLTA'07, Vancouver, Canada, Sept. 2007.

[3] P. Wambacq and W. Sansen, "Distortion Analysis of Analog Integrated Circuits," 1st ed. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Harlow, England, 1998.

[4] Stephan A. Maas, "Nonlinear Microwave and RF Circuits," Artech House, Boston, London, 2nd ed. , 1988.

[5] S. El-Rabaie, Vincent F. Fusco, and Carson Stewart, "Harmonic Balance Evaluation of Nonlinear Microwave Circuits-A Tutorial Approach," IEEE Transactions on Education, Vol. 31, No. 3, Aug. 1988.

[6] http://www.ecircuitcenter.com/SpiceTopics/Overview/Overview.htm.

[7] Lawrence W. Nagel, "SPICE2: A Program to Simulate Semiconductor Circuits," Memo UCB/ERL M520, University of California, Berkeley, CA, 1975.

[8] Andrei Vladimirescu, "The Spice Book," John Wiley & Sons, Inc. , 1994.

[9] Ron Keilkowski, "Inside SPICE," McGraw Hill, 1994.

[10] "The Optima Manual," The Hatfield Polytechnic Numerical OptimizationCenter, Issue 6, July 1994.

[11] M. Nakhla and J. Vlach, "A Piecewise Harmonic Balance Technique for Determination of the Periodic Response of Nonlinear Systems," IEEE Transactions Circuits System, Vol. 23, pp. 85–91, Feb. 1976.

[12] A. Ushida and L. Chua, "Frequency-Domain Analysis of Nonlinear Circuits Driven by Multi-Tone Signal," IEEE Transactions Circuits System, Vol. 31, pp. 766–778, Sept. 1984.

[13] K. Kundert and A. Sangiovanni Vincentelli, "Simulation of Nonlinear Circuits in the Frequency domain," IEEE Transactions Computer-Aided Design, Vol. 5, pp. 521–535, Oct. 1986.

[14] V. Rizzoli, C. Cecchetti, A. Lipparini, and F. Fastri, "General Purpose Harmonic Balance Analysis of Nonlinear Microwave Circuits under Multi-Tone Excitation," IEEE Transactions MTT. , Vol. 36, pp. 1650–1660, Dec. 1988.

[15] K. Kundert, J. White, and A. Sangiovanni Vincentelli, "Steady-State Methods for Simulating Analog and Microwave Circuits," Norwell, MA: Kluwer, 1990.

[16] D. Weiner and J. Spina, "Sinusoidal Analysis and Modeling of Weakly Nonlinear Circuits," New York: Van Nostrand, 1980.

[17] S. Chisholm and L. Nagel, "Efficient Computer Simulation of Distortion in Electronic Circuits," IEEE Transactions Circuit Theory, Vol. 20, pp. 742–745, Nov. 1973.

[18] K. Kundert, "The Designer’s Guide to SPICE & SPECTRE," Norwell, MA: Kluwer, 1995.

[19] M. Oda, Y. Yamagami, Y. Nishio, J. Kawata, and A. Ushida, "A New Spice-Oriented Frequency-Domain Optimization Technique," ISCAS, pp. 3694-3697, 2006.

[20] Dani Tanni, and Roni Khazaka, "Computation of IP3 Using Single-Tone Moments Analysis," Proceedings of the Conference on Design, Automation and Test in Europe, EDAA, 2009.